MENU
Weekly Specials
Available Monday to Friday only.
$16
CHEF’S PAIRING: SOUP & SANDWICH
Roast Turkey Club & cup of soup
$16
$32
FAROE ISLAND SALMON FREEKEH BOWL
avocado, watercress, sun-dried figs, marcona almonds, citrus vinaigrette
$32
$24
ROAST TURKEY & BLACK FOREST HAM
brie cheese, granny smith apple, baby arugula, cranberry aioli, ciabatta
$24
Starters and Shares
$12
CHEDDAR PULL-APART BRIOCHE
vermont cheddar, whipped honey butter
$12
$20
GRILLED SHRIMP
cherry tomato, feta, pearl couscous, castelvetrano olives, basil pesto
$20
$15
MOZZARELLA SKEWERS
panko-crusted ciliegine, tomato chutney, micro basil
$15
$21
BURRATA & PROSCIUTTO BOARD
sourdough toast, olive oil, smoked sea salt
$21
$18
GINGER CHIPOTLE STEAK TACOS
pineapple pico de gallo, avocado, corn tortilla
$18
$23
CHARRED OCTOPUS
red pepper hummus, crispy chickpeas, chorizo vinaigrette
$23
$22
EVERYTHING CRUSTED TUNA
shiitake mushrooms, ponzu, scallion
$22
$18
WAGYU BABY BURGERS
dry rubbed uncured bacon, pear & onion chutney, brie, brioche
$18
add burger $7
$18
CRISPY CHICKEN WINGS
gochujang with kimchi ranch or classic buffalo with blue cheese
$18
$22
POINT JUDITH CALAMARI
furikake, shishito peppers, grilled lemon, herb garlic aioli
$22
$19
MARGHERITA PINSA
fresh mozzarella, roasted tomato, basil pesto, parmigiano
$19
Soup
MP
CHEF CARLOS’ FAMOUS SOUP
Ask your server about our daily offering
MP
Salads
Add to your salad: Falafel $6, Chicken $9, Salmon $12 or Steak $13
$19
SOUTHWEST
roasted corn, beans, queso fresco, tomato, avocado, yellow rice, baby greens, creamy ranch
$19
$19
BRUSSELS CAESAR
shredded brussels sprouts, kale, asiago, crostini, grilled lemon
$19
$20
HARVEST
butternut squash, goat cheese, sun-dried cranberries, apple, brussels sprouts, pumpkin seeds, market greens, apple cider vinaigrette
$20
Sandwiches
$17
CRISPY FALAFEL
cucumber, pickled beets, red onion, tomato, arugula, dill, tahini dressing, grilled pita
$17
$20
SPICY CRISPY CHICKEN SANDWICH
slaw, pickles, spicy mayo, potato bun
$20
$19
ROAST TURKEY CLUB
avocado, bacon, cracked black pepper aioli, sourdough
$19
$23
TUSCAN GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICH
fontina, baby arugula, roasted tomato chutney, basil pesto aioli, tomato focaccia
$23
$24
SPICED SALMON SANDWICH
avocado salsa, tomato, microgreens, remoulade, ciabatta
$24
$26
BRAISED SHORT RIB
french onion marmalade, smoked gouda, baby arugula, horseradish aioli, ciabatta
$26
Burgers
Served with salad or fries
$21
HONEY JALAPEÑO TURKEY BURGER
avocado crema, sweet corn salsa, cilantro, potato bun
$21
$25
ANGRY BURGER
crumbled blue cheese, crispy onions, Frank’s hot sauce, sesame seed potato bun
$25
$22
MAGGIE’S BURGER
special blend beef patty, lettuce & tomato, sesame seed potato bun
$22
add bacon $3, american, cheddar or swiss cheese $2
$26
GREEK LAMB BURGER
fire-roasted tomatoes, baby spinach, feta, roast garlic aioli, potato bun
$26
Burger Specials
$20 BURGER & BEER
Available weekends only
Mains
$32
ROASTED HALF CHICKEN
garlic spinach, whipped Boursin mash potatoes, demi-glace
$32
$36
FAROE ISLAND SALMON
smashed roasted butternut squash, crispy brussels sprouts, beurre blanc
$36
$29
SHORT RIB CASCATELLI
mushrooms, spinach, cherry tomato, parmigiano
$29
$46
STEAK FRITES AU POIVRE
12 oz cast-iron seared NY Strip, peppercorn brandy cream
$46
Classics
$24
SHEPHERD’S PIE
add cheddar $2
$24
$23
CHICKEN POT PIE
$23
$26
FISH & CHIPS
beer-battered atlantic cod, grilled lemon, house-made tartar
$26
Desserts
CHEF'S SEASONAL SELECTION
$12
WARM MOLTEN CHOCOLATE LAVA CAKE
raspberry coulis, fresh cream, mint
$12
$12
RUSTIC APPLE TART
vanilla bean ice cream, cinnamon sugar, salted caramel
$12
Specialty Cocktails
$18
The Gilded Peel
Grey Goose, Pamplemousse, dry vermouth, lime, simple, saline
$18
$19
Pinkies Up
Neversink Gin, Empress, Velvet Falernum, Orgeat, lemon
$19
$19
Wish You Were Here
Pisco, Malibu, coconut, lime zest, lemon, egg white, saline, bitters
$19
$18
Maggie’s Mirage
Casamigos Blanco, aloe vera, hibiscus, lime, agave
$18
$20
Teddy’s Old Fashioned
chamomile-infused Teeling Irish Whiskey, honey, toasted almond bitters
$20
$21
How Do You Do?
Tito’s, Peanut Butter Whisky, Frangelico, Borghetti, cold brew
$21
$19
Orchard Reverie
Fort Hamilton Double Barrel, apple syrup, Porto, lemon, chocolate bitters
$19
$20
Oaxacan Ruby
Ilegal Mezcal, Aperol, Cocchi Americano, strawberries, pink peppercorn
$20
Mocktails
Spike your mocktail $5
$13
I’ll Drive
raspberry, citrus, club soda
$13
$14
Out Of Office
coconut, lime zest, citrus, Fever-Tree Lime Yuzu Soda
$14
$13
Fleur Fizz
hibiscus, fresh lime, sparkling water
$13
Draft Beers
Did you know? Maggie’s Place is the very last of the original bars that served Guinness in NYC. Here, Guinness isn’t just a pint—it’s a tradition woven into the soul of Maggie’s. We take our time for the perfect pour, because some things are worth waiting for.
$9.50
Allagash White
$9.50
$9.50
Brooklyn Lager
$9.50
$9.50
Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA
$9.50
$10
Down East Cider
$10
$9.50
Fiddlehead IPA
$9.50
$10
Guinness
$10
$9.50
Lagunitas IPA
$9.50
$9.50
Stella Artois
$9.50
Rotating Selection
Please ask your server for our current offerings.
Canned and Bottled Beers
$8
Athletic Brewing Lager/IPA (Non Alcoholic)
$8
$7.5
Bud Light
$7.5
$7.5
Budweiser
$7.5
$8
Corona
$8
$15
Duvel Belgian Blonde Ale
$15
$9
Guinness 0.0 (Non Alcoholic)
$9
$8
Heineken 0.0 (Non Alcoholic)
$8
$8
Heineken
$8
$12
High Noon
$12
$10
Kills Boro Killsner
$10
$9
Magners Cider
$9
$7.5
Michelob Ultra
$7.5
$9
Montauk Seasonal
$9
$12
Surfside
$12
$13
Wölffer No. 139 Dry Rose Cider
$13
Sparkling Wine
$16
Prosecco
Mionetto, Treviso, IT 187ml
$16
$18
Rose Prosecco
Mionetto, Treviso, IT 187ml
$18
$150
Brut Champagne
Veuve Clicquot, Champagne, FR
$150
$200
Brut Champagne “Imperial”
Moet & Chandon, Champagne, FR
$200
White Wine
$15
Riff
Pinot Grigio Delle Venezie, Organic, IT
$15
Bottle: $60
$17
Southern Lines
Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough, New Zealand
$17
Bottle: $60
$16
Domaine Chene
Macon La Roche Vineuse Chardonnay, France
$16
Bottle: $64
Orange
$16
Populis
Blended Macerated, Richmond, CA
$16
Bottle: $64
Rosé
$16
Rosé
La Chevaliere, Pays d’Oc, France
$16
Bottle: $64
Red Wine
$16
Yalumba
Pinot Noir, South Australia
$16
Bottle: $60
$17
Domaine Vallot
Malbec Blend Cotes Du Rhone La Coriancon, FR
$17
Bottle: $64
$18
Saveurs du Temps
Cabernet Sauvignon Pays D’Oc, France
$18
Bottle: $78